A salary increase at senior level needs a clear case and the right decision process. Your results matter, but so do the scope of the role, the organisation’s pay structure, affordability and who has authority to approve a change. Strong performance does not automatically remove those constraints.
Before requesting a review, decide what you want reconsidered: your base salary, your role’s grade, the incentive arrangements or the overall package. These are different discussions. Treating them as one general request for more money makes it harder to reach a useful decision.
1. Identify the reason for the salary increase
Start with the change you can explain and support. Is the role materially larger than when your package was agreed? Has market evidence moved? Are you seeking recognition for sustained performance within the existing role, or negotiating the terms of a promotion?
For example, taking accountability for a second region may justify reviewing the role itself. Completing a demanding project within an unchanged remit may support a performance discussion. Neither establishes a particular increase on its own.
The CIPD’s guidance on pay structures distinguishes progression within a pay band from inflation-related rises and promotion into a higher band. Ask which process applies to your request and what evidence it requires.
Cost-of-living pressure is a legitimate concern. You do not have to pretend otherwise. For an individual senior-level adjustment, however, also explain why the requested change is appropriate for the role and the employer’s reward framework.
2. Compare equivalent roles and the whole package
A job title is an unreliable benchmark on its own. A finance director in a single-country business may have a different remit from a group finance director with multiple subsidiaries, external funding responsibilities and a board reporting line.
When reviewing salary guides, advertised ranges or information from specialist recruiters, compare:
- Sector, geography and the period the data covers.
- Business scale, ownership and operating complexity.
- Team, budget and decision-making responsibility.
- Whether the figure is base pay, guaranteed package or includes incentives.
- The quality of the comparison and any obvious gaps in the sample.
The CIPD’s overview of job evaluation and market pricing explains that internal and external role information both matter. A salary survey can support a discussion. It does not prove that your employer must pay a particular figure.
Separate guaranteed remuneration from amounts that depend on performance or future events. In a South African package, establish what is included in the quoted cost to company, including employer contributions and benefits. Check the actual offer or contract rather than assuming two employers use the term identically.
For incentives, ask about targets, discretion, payment dates and conditions. For equity, understand vesting, exercise requirements where applicable and what happens if you leave. Do not count an uncertain future award as cash available today. Obtain appropriate professional advice if the contractual or tax implications are material to your decision.
3. Build a one-page evidence brief
Choose a small number of outcomes that demonstrate the contribution relevant to your request. For each, record the starting situation, your responsibility, the result and how it can be checked.
An operations leader might discuss service reliability, working capital and a change in regional accountability. A people leader might focus on a verified succession outcome, a critical workforce transition or an improvement in retention within a clearly defined group. Select evidence that reflects your remit rather than forcing every achievement into a revenue claim.
Be precise about attribution. Distinguish the work you led from the work the wider team delivered. Separate recurring savings from a one-off reduction, and realised benefits from forecasts. Use approved internal figures and identify the period being measured.
Your brief should contain:
- The present role and the material changes in scope.
- Two or three relevant, supportable outcomes.
- The strongest comparable market evidence, with its limits.
- The adjustment you are requesting and its proposed effective date.
- The questions that require a decision.
Keep supporting detail available, but do not bury the request under a presentation about everything you have done. Never invent a competing offer or inflate results to make the case stronger.
4. Find the approval route before the budget closes
Ask when remuneration decisions are prepared, not only when they are announced. Your manager may need to submit a recommendation before the annual review meeting. A change to a senior executive package may also require input from HR, a remuneration committee or another authorised decision-maker, depending on the organisation.
Find out who can sponsor the request, who can approve it and whether it belongs in the ordinary review cycle or a separate role-evaluation process. Give the relevant person time to assess the evidence.
If you are taking on a substantially larger role, discuss the package and review process before accepting open-ended additional accountability where possible. Agree the remit, decision rights, support and review date. A vague promise to revisit pay later is not a defined outcome.
5. Make a specific request and discuss the response
Open with the reason for the review, then make the request plainly. This illustrative wording is a structure to adapt, not a claim about an actual employee:
I would like to review my package against the regional remit I now hold. My responsibilities have expanded to include the second operation, and I have summarised the outcomes and comparable roles here. I am requesting an adjustment to my guaranteed package from the next agreed review date. What further information is needed, and who needs to approve it?
Use your own amount and date when you have enough evidence to support them. Avoid treating a percentage suggested by someone online as a universal negotiating target.
If the employer proposes a bonus instead of a base-pay change, compare what each option means. A one-off payment does not alter recurring guaranteed pay. An incentive may be attractive, but the conditions and likelihood of payment matter. Ask for the terms in writing before deciding.
Keep the discussion factual without becoming rigid. Listen for whether the objection concerns your evidence, the role’s grade, timing or affordability. Each calls for a different next step.
6. Leave with a decision or a defined review
If the request is approved, confirm the amount, package components, effective date, conditions and responsible administrator. Check that the written confirmation matches the agreement.
If it is declined or deferred, ask what would need to change. Agree a review date and measurable criteria if there is a realistic route forward. Clarify whether additional responsibilities are temporary and what support accompanies them.
If there is no credible route, consider your options without making an ultimatum you are not prepared to follow. An external role should be assessed on its mandate, leadership environment and full terms, as well as remuneration. A higher headline figure can come with different risks and obligations.
Keep the career evidence current
The record you prepare for a pay review can also reveal whether your career documents describe your current level accurately. Keep confidential remuneration and business information out of public profiles.
If your next step involves a broader leadership role, Elite Executive Career Solutions can help present your experience through executive career documents and positioning. A stronger presentation supports a clear account of your work; it does not guarantee a salary outcome.
Frequently asked questions
How much of a salary increase should I request?
There is no single suitable percentage. Use the role’s scope, credible comparisons, the structure of your current package and the reason for the review to support a specific request.
Do I need another offer before asking?
No. A review can be based on your existing role and contribution. If you have a genuine offer, assess it on its own merits and discuss it honestly rather than using a bluff.
What should I do if the business cannot afford an increase?
Clarify whether the constraint is temporary and whether a dated review is realistic. Assess any alternatives on their actual terms, and decide whether the role still supports your longer-term goals.
